Prices and delivery update for your selected market.
Prices and delivery update for your selected market.
The MUNO journal · Choose your cleansing texture
A cleansing oil starts as a liquid; a cleansing balm starts solid and melts as you massage it. Both can be a makeup-removing first cleanse. The better choice is the formula and format you enjoy using, rather than a rule that one texture suits every skin type.
Choose an oil if you prefer a fluid texture and a pump bottle. Choose a balm if you prefer scooping a solid texture from a pot. You normally choose one for this step; you do not need an oil and a balm in the same cleanse.
The difference you notice first is the format. An oil is already fluid when dispensed. A balm needs to be scooped and worked gently over the skin. Beauty of Joseon explains this distinction in its cleansing balm FAQ: both formats can start a double cleanse, but they feel different.
| What matters | Cleansing oil | Cleansing balm |
|---|---|---|
| Starting texture | Liquid | Solid balm that melts |
| Dispensing | Often a pump bottle | Usually a pot and spatula |
| Application | Follow the individual label | Follow the individual label |
| Choice to make | Do you like a fluid texture? | Do you like a scoopable texture? |
These are format differences, not a ranking of cleansing strength. Two oils can feel quite different, just as two balms can. Check the particular product rather than assuming that a thicker starting texture is automatically more nourishing or a thinner one is more suitable for oily skin.
Start with the small practical details. If you want to dispense product straight into your palm, a pump may be convenient. If you like controlling a scoop with a spatula, a balm may fit your routine. For a washbag, compare the actual container dimensions and closure; neither format is a promise against leaks.
Next, read the ingredients on the product you are considering, especially if you already know something you prefer to avoid. A texture name alone does not tell you whether a cleanser contains fragrance or particular botanical oils. There is no need to buy two formats simply to discover which is fashionable.
A useful shopping checklist is: Do I like the dispensing method? Are the directions clear? Is the ingredient list suitable for my preferences? Am I choosing this to replace my current first cleanser, rather than adding an extra step without a purpose?
SKIN1004 Madagascar Centella Light Cleansing Oil is the liquid option here. SKIN1004 describes a light, watery texture and use for removing makeup and sunscreen. Its official directions start with dry hands and a dry face: gently massage the oil, add a little water to form a milky emulsion, then rinse thoroughly with lukewarm water.
BANILA CO Clean It Zero Cleansing Balm Original offers the scoopable alternative. The brand’s product instructions say to use the included spatula, massage onto dry skin with fingertips, add water to emulsify and rinse well with lukewarm water. The melting step is part of the application, not an instruction to scrub harder.
When trying either of these products, follow its complete directions, including adding water and rinsing. A cleanser that has not been used as directed is a poor basis for comparing textures. Do not judge an oil against a balm after skipping one product’s emulsifying step.
Keep the rest of your familiar evening routine simple while making the comparison. You could note whether dispensing feels convenient and whether you enjoy the texture, rather than changing several products at once and losing track of your preference.
For general face-washing technique, the American Academy of Dermatology recommends gentle fingertips, avoiding scrubbing and rinsing with lukewarm water. General advice to wet the face for a face wash does not replace a specific oil or balm’s directions to begin dry.
For the first cleanse discussed here, choose one. If you are planning a double cleanse, the next product is a water-based cleanser, not a second oil-based format. BANILA CO explains that pairing in its cleansing balm guide.
The solid format alone is not enough to make that decision. Compare the individual formula and your preferences. Avoid buying on the assumption that every balm is richer after rinsing than every oil.
Not for the SKIN1004 cleanser described above: it is a rinse-off product. Follow its emulsifying and rinsing instructions. A cleansing oil is a different step from a leave-on facial oil.
Continue with the skincare you normally use, rather than building a longer routine just because you changed cleanser texture. Our moisturiser application guide explains a simple finishing step.
Sources and product directions · Checked 11 October 2026. Product directions and labels take priority; this guide does not claim personal testing.
No account yet?
Create an Account
